Bagel Bros Cafe

Bagel Bros Cafe absolutely nails it. I ordered the Nova Lox on an everything bagel and it was flawless — fresh, balanced, and clearly made with care. Their house-made spread takes it even further, smooth and flavorful without overpowering the salmon. What sealed it for me was hearing every table around me — actual New Yorkers — saying the same thing: this is the closest you’ll get to a true New York bagel outside the city. No gimmicks, just the real deal.

Best Bagels I’ve had in FL! Closest thing to an authentic NY Bagel sandwich. Sometimes it gets a little busy, but the staff works through the orders quickly while maintaining their standard! It’s busy at times because the regulars know the quality! I would definitely recommend this bagel shop!

Great local bagel store. NY style bagels with quick and friendly service. No nonsense bagels with lots of variety, that said the standards were as expected and will certainly be back. Surprising the dearth of quality bagel places in the area but this place makes up for it. Not sure about all the comments about parking, had no issues and while not a real sit down restaurant, they do have some tables inside and outside for a quick bite and coffee.

Tried this place for the first time today and it was fantastic! I’m from NY so I can confirm that the bagels are authentic. So we got an egg sandwich and lox and we were both very happy with the quality and quantity. Parking was easy, and the staff was very friendly. We will definitely be regulars here!

My daughter and I stopped in this morning to finally try their bagels, and we were not disappointed. First their customer service is amazing. They have a great selection of bagels to choose from. I was happy to find sea salt bagels they are my favorite and not offered at many places. We both kept it simple and got bagels with cream cheese and loved them. I highly recommend trying them out if you have not.

The bagels and cream cheese are excellent. Staff is always very nice. The last couple times we have been there, our order always has an additional charge on it. This past time I asked why the additional charge for a veggie bagel (regular bagel) no cheese or veggies on top. I was told certain bagels like the chocolate chip and the colorful bagel is extra. Why is veggie extra when the ones with cheese and toppings ones are not. The menu board states all bagels the one price with cream cheese or without. Not that .50 cents is a lot but over a lot of different customers a day it adds up. Just feel they should honor the prices on the menu. Parking is also not easy access.