Bagel Bros Cafe Menu

1216 S Bay St, Eustis, FL 32726, United States
$$$ Cafe
(34 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

The menu at Bagel Bros Cafe features a variety of sandwich options centered around their artisan bagels and breads. It is organized into distinct groups, including Artisan Sandwiches – The Foot Longs, Paninis, and Hot Deli Sandwiches, each offering different sandwich preparations and fillings.

Artisan Sandwiches – The Foot Longs include several 12-inch sandwiches served with a pickle, such as the Bagel Bros Club Sandwich made with turkey, bacon, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, and onions on thick white bread; the New York Footlong featuring provolone, Boar's Head turkey, lettuce, tomato, and onions with an option to add bacon; and the Italian Footlong which includes salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onions, also with an optional bacon addition.

Paninis offer grilled sandwich options with various fillings, including Grilled Turkey with tomato, spinach, honey mustard, and Swiss cheese; a Veggie option with mushrooms, onions, roasted red pepper, pesto sauce, lettuce, tomato, and Swiss cheese; and Grilled Chicken with pesto sauce, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.

Hot Deli Sandwiches feature choices like Philly Cheesesteak served with french fries and a pickle, Corned Beef portions served with a pickle, and Pastrami on any bagel with Swiss cheese, grilled onions, and spicy mustard. The menu includes a consumer advisory regarding the consumption of raw or undercooked meats or other items that may pose a risk to certain individuals.

This menu suits a range of eating occasions, from quick breakfast or brunch options featuring bagel-based sandwiches to heartier lunch choices with hot deli sandwiches and paninis. The offerings cater to customers looking for casual, quick-service dining focused on sandwiches made with artisan breads and quality deli ingredients.

Breakfast - Pancakes & French Toast

  • French Toast Wedges
    US$7.99
  • Pancakes (2)
    US$9.99
  • Blueberry Or Chocolate Chip Pancakes
    US$10.99
  • Pancakes (2) With Eggs
    US$13.99

Breakfast - Breakfast Sandwiches

  • Bacon On A Bagel
    US$7.99
  • Taylor On A Bagel
    US$7.99
  • Ham & 2 Eggs On A Bagel
    US$8.98
  • Steak, 2 Eggs, & American Cheese
    US$14.55
  • Bacon 2 Eggs & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$9.49
  • Sausage 2 Eggs & Cheese
    US$9.49
  • Steak & 2 Eggs
    US$13.80
  • Ham & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$8.49
  • Sausage & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$8.49
  • Ham 2 Eggs Cheese On A Bagel
    US$8.49
  • Taylor & 2 Eggs On A Bagel
    US$8.99
  • Ham On A Bagel (Breakfast Sandwich)
    US$7.99
  • Cheese On A Bagel
    US$3.49
  • 2 Eggs & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$7.24
  • Taylor & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$8.49
  • Bacon & 2 Eggs On A Bagel
    US$8.99
  • Taylor 2 Eggs & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$9.49
  • Steak & American Cheese
    US$10.57
  • Sausage On A Bagel
    US$7.99
  • Vegan. Sausage, Spinach, Carrot, & Vegan Cheddar
    US$7.49
  • Sausage & 2 Eggs On A Bagel
    US$8.99
  • 2 Eggs On A Bagel
    US$6.49
  • Bacon & Cheese On A Bagel
    US$8.49

Artisan Sandwiches - The Foot Longs

  • The Bagel Bros Club Sandwich W/Pickle
    US$15.48
  • The New York Footlong W/Pickle
    US$15.48
  • The Italian Footlong W/Pickle
    US$14.49
  • Veggie Footlong W/Pickle
    US$13.48
  • The Bagel Bros Turkey Or Ham Wrap W/Pickle
    US$10.24
  • The Footlong Ham W/Pickle
    US$15.48
  • The Bros BLT W/Pickle
    US$10.98

Catering

  • Bros Breakfast Eggstravaganza
    US$39.99
  • Bros Pastry Basket With Picnic Basket
    US$39.99
  • Bros Saladicious
    US$39.99
  • Bros Family Breakfast Pack
    US$39.99

Quesadillas

  • Quesadillas
    US$10.99

Beverages

  • 20oz Mt Dew
    US$2.99
  • 20oz Diet Pepsi
    US$2.99
  • Blue Gatorade 20oz
    US$2.49
  • Pure Leaf Unsweet Tea
    US$3.49
  • Orange Gatorade 20oz
    US$2.49
  • Pure Leaf Sweet Tea
    US$3.49
  • Tropicana Apple Juice
    US$3.89
  • Nestle Chocolate Milk
    US$3.79
  • Starbucks Frappuccino Mocha
    US$4.79
  • Starry (Sprite) 20oz
    US$2.99
  • Tropicana Orange Juice
    US$3.89
  • Starbucks Frappuccino Caramel
    US$4.70
  • Water 20oz
    US$2.29
  • Nestle Strawberry Milk
    US$3.79
  • Starbucks Frappuccino Vanilla
    US$4.70
  • 20oz Pepsi
    US$2.99

Burgers

  • Mushroom Cheeseburger W/ NY Home Fries
    US$11.49
  • Beef Burger W/ NY Home Fries
    US$10.99
  • Cheeseburger W/ NY Home Fries
    US$11.49
  • Bacon Cheeseburger W/ NY Home Fries
    US$13.99

Breakfast - Egg Plates

  • Eggs (2) With Sausage, Bacon, Ham, Or Taylor Ham & Potatoes
    US$9.49
  • *Bagel Benedict With Potatoes
    US$10.99
  • Lox, Eggs, Onions*, & Potatoes
    US$10.79
  • Eggs (2)
    US$6.49
  • Eggs (2) With Potatoes
    US$7.49
  • Brooklyn Special
    US$10.99

Low-Fat Wraps

  • Tuna Salad
    US$8.75
  • Grilled Chicken Ranch
    US$11.79
  • Veggie
    US$8.25
  • Chicken Salad
    US$8.75

Coffee

  • Latte
    US$6.54
  • New York House Blend (16oz)
    US$3.99
  • ICED COFFEE HOUSE BLEND
    US$4.79
  • Espresso Single
    US$3.99
  • Cappuccino
    US$5.99
  • Flavored Latte
    US$6.20
  • New York Breakfast Blend (16 Oz)
    US$3.99
  • Espresso Double
    US$4.79

Bagels

  • Bagels (Baker's Dozen)
    US$22.50
  • Bagels (Half Dozen)
    US$10.64
  • Bagels (Single)
    US$2.69

On a Bagel or Roll

  • Specialty Cream Cheeses
    US$4.99
  • Cream Cheese
    US$4.79
  • Sliced Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
    US$10.99
  • Sliced Nova Lox
    US$11.99
  • Single Bagel
    US$2.69
  • Lox & Cream Cheese Spread
    US$5.99
  • Butter
    US$3.49

Breakfast - Low-Fat Breakfast Wraps

  • Bacon, Sausage, Or Ham, Egg, & Cheese
    US$8.24
  • Plain Eggs (2)
    US$4.49

Breakfast - Omelettes

  • Greek Omelette
    US$12.99
  • Plain Omelette
    US$10.99
  • Ham Omelette
    US$14.49
  • Vegetable Omelette
    US$13.99
  • Western Omelette
    US$15.99
  • Spinach Omelette
    US$11.49
  • Mushroom Omelette
    US$11.49
  • Sausage Omelette
    US$14.49
  • Bacon Omelette
    US$14.49

Artisan Sandwiches - Famous Sandwiches

  • Tuna Sandwich On Toasted White Bread W/Pickle
    US$9.75
  • Egg Salad On Toasted White Bread W/Pickle
    US$9.75
  • Chicken Salad Keiser Sandwich W/Pickle
    US$9.75
  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich W/Pickle
    US$4.69

Breakfast - Bakery Items

  • New York Crumb Cake
    US$3.99
  • Chocolate Layer Cake
    US$6.49
  • Black & White Cookie
    US$2.99
  • Chunk Cookies
    US$3.49
  • Muffins
    US$3.99
  • Carrot Cake
    US$6.49
  • New York Cheesecake
    US$5.99

Boars Head 6" Hoagies

  • Turkey Or Ham Hoagie 6"
    US$8.29
  • The New York Hoagie 6"
    US$8.19
  • The Italian Hoagie 6"
    US$8.19
  • The Veggie Hoagie 6"
    US$7.24

Spreads & Lox

  • 8oz Cream Cheese Spreads
    US$4.99
  • 8oz Lox Spread
    US$5.19

Paninis

  • Grilled Turkey
    US$10.49
  • Veggie
    US$8.25
  • Grilled Chicken
    US$12.89

Artisan Sandwiches - Hot Deli Sandwiches

  • Philly Cheesesteak W/ Pickle
    US$11.99
  • Corned Beef (6 Oz) W/Pickle
    US$12.49
  • Pastrami (6 Oz) W/Pickle
    US$12.49
  • Hot Veggie Sub With Side W/Pickle
    US$9.25
  • Grilled Chicken, Mushroom, & Cheese W/Pickle
    US$12.49
  • Grilled Chicken W/Pickle
    US$11.49
  • Grilled Chicken Club W/Pickle
    US$12.89
  • Reuben W/Pickle
    US$14.99
  • Tuna Melt W/Pickle
    US$9.25